Spanish Grand Prix strategy report

F1 News
Monday, 11 May 2015 at 16:09
jm1510my389
Formula Legend Strategy Report – Spanish Grand Prix 2015
Round 5 – 66 Laps – 4.655km per lap – 307.104km race distance – medium tyre wear
Round five of the F1 2015 season took place at the Circuit de Barcelona-Catalunya in Barcelona, Spain. With the sport returning to Europe and a track famous for being great for testing, there were plenty of updates and upgrades brought to the race.It wasn’t a thriller, but it rarely is in Spain. However, it was an interesting and tactical, strategic race, with Nico Rosberg winning on a two-stop strategy and Lewis Hamilton pitting three times to recover to second place. Sebastian Vettel was third, but Ferrari looks to have lost ground to Mercedes.There were lots of talking points from the Spanish Grand Prix on the subject of strategy. Here is Formula Legend’s strategy report for the race:

Start Tyres

As the tyre warmers were removed in preparation for the formation lap, it was revealed that all 20 runners would start the race on the medium tyre – Pirelli predicted before the Spanish Grand Prix that this would be the preferred race tyre with the track conditions and temperatures.

Switching Strategy

Mercedes has admitted that it switched Hamilton to a three-stop strategy, doing something different and aggressive in an attempt to pass Vettel. The Englishman dropped behind the Ferrari driver at the start and couldn’t find a way through in the opening two stints.

A slow first pit stop didn’t help matters and meant he failed to get the undercut on his rival. Having switched strategy, he used the hard tyre for his third stint and then emerged from his final stop ahead of Vettel and on the medium tyre.

He was then able to quickly pull away and closed the gap to Rosberg. However, he ran out of laps to really make inroads and finished 17 seconds further back. He struggled to pass Vettel on track due to the lack of overtaking spots at the Circuit de Barcelona-Catalunya, Ferrari’s improved straight line speed and a lack of grip when running in tight formation – he seemed to lose ground through the final chicane when following the SF15-T.

Because Ferrari kept to a two-stop race, Vettel never really had a chance to fight Hamilton – Ferrari appears to have lost some pace in the fight with Mercedes for the top spot, but he could have challenged and even kept Hamilton behind if Ferrari had reacted to Mercedes’ strategy call and switched as well.

Iceman’s recovery

Kimi Raikkonen wasn’t happy with his car after qualifying and lined up seventh on the grid. A great start saw him rise to fifth and Ferrari opted to go for a similar strategy to the one he completed in Bahrain, with a long middle stint on the harder compound Pirelli tyre.

However, this time it didn’t work out. He wasn’t fast enough through that stint and it meant he spent the final 19 laps stuck behind the Williams of Valtteri Bottas. With strong straight line speed from the Mercedes power unit and a lack of places to pass, Raikkonen had to settle for fifth.

Two vs three stops

13 of the 20 race starters went for a two-stop race, which on paper was seen to be slightly slower, but with less risk of getting caught behind slower cars and in traffic. Hamilton was the only driver in the top five to stop three times, and this was in a bid to pass Vettel after his poor start.

Overall, the two-stop outperformed the three, with five other drivers mirroring Hamilton’s strategy – Felipe Massa, Nico Hulkenberg, Jenson Button, Will Stevens and Roberto Merhi. Williams opted to put the former on a three-stop strategy due to higher tyre wear, which his team-mate Valtteri Bottas didn’t suffer and ended up changing the other way, from three to two stops. Massa made up positions at the start but the strategy didn’t help him gain any more places.

Four Stops

Pastor Maldonado failed to finish the race after retiring on lap 45, but he still stopped four times. However, this was not due to strategy. Instead, it was because he made contact with his team-mate at Turn 3 and damaged his rear wing endplate.

He had to make an additional pit stop after his first trip so the team could take a look at the rear wing and see what could be done. Eventually, they just ripped off the entire right endplate and sent him out. He then pitted for the fourth and final time to exit the race.

Trouble in the pits

It was a busy pit lane in Spain, with a new incidents cropping up. Fernando Alonso suffered brake issues and when he pitted, he overshot his box by quite some way. Fortunately he didn’t hit anyway.

The same can’t be said for Romain Grosjean, who did the same thing – thanks to a “slippery pit box according to Lotus – and ran into his front jack man. It was a hefty hit but the crew member soldiered on bravely, with Grosjean able to return to the race.

Jack Leslie

Pirelli Strategy Infographics

SC
SC

Circuit de Catalunya, Barcelona, Spain. Sunday 10 May 2015. Valtteri Bottas, Williams FW37 Mercedes, leads Max Verstappen, Toro Rosso STR10 Renault, Kimi Raikkonen, Ferrari SF-15T, Felipe Massa, Williams FW37 Mercedes, and the remainder of the field at the start. Photo: Glenn Dunbar/Williams ref: Digital Image _89P6383

BARCELLONA (SPAGNA) - 10/05/15© FOTO STUDIO COLOMBO PER FERRARI MEDIA (© COPYRIGHT FREE)

1431276401914

CEpO5nbWgAAwXV7

Daniil+Kvyat+Spanish+F1+Grand+Prix+_66JiIJdkT-x

Felipe+Nasr+Spanish+F1+Grand+Prix+HqiTw9gJgm_x

Nico Hulkenberg (GER) Sahara Force India F1 VJM08 makes a pit stop.Spanish Grand Prix, Sunday 10th May 2015. Barcelona, Spain.

Romain Grosjean (FRA) Lotus F1 E23 makes a pit stop.Spanish Grand Prix, Sunday 10th May 2015. Barcelona, Spain.

Felipe Nasr (BRA), Sauber F1 Team. Circuit de Barcelona-Catalunya.

Nico+Rosberg+Spanish+F1+Grand+Prix+OtW3d-uBGW_x

F1Spain2015_HZ_08209

SCSafety Car
No Safety Car -

Redbull3. Ricciardo
Start P10
Medium Qual + 13 laps Pit 22.440
Medium 29 laps Pit 24.884
Hard 23 laps -
Finish P7

Ferrari5. Vettel
Start P3
Medium Qual + 14 laps Pit 21.762
Medium 26 laps Pit 21.836
Hard 26 laps -
Finish P3

Merc6. Rosberg
Start P1
Medium Qual + 15 laps Pit 21.870
Medium 30 laps Pit 22.452
Hard 21 laps -
Finish P3

Ferrari7. Raikkonen
Start P7
Medium Qual + 17 laps Pit 22.623
Hard 24 laps Pit 21.789
Medium 25 laps -
Finished P5

Redbull8. Grosjean
Start P11
Medium Qual + 15 laps Pit 23.309
Medium 25 laps Pit 33.256
Hard 25 laps -
Finish P8

Sauber9. Ericsson
Start P16
Medium 18 laps Pit 25.272
Medium 27 laps Pit 22.872
Hard 20 laps -
Finished P14

FI11. Perez
Start P18
Medium 19 laps Pit 22.468
Hard 17 laps 22.426
Medium 29 laps -
Finished P13

Sauber12. Nasr
Start P15
Medium 12 laps Pit 22.677
Hard 27 laps 23.186
Hard 26 laps -0
Finished P12

Redbull13. Maldonado
Start P12
Medium 14 lap Pit 24.976
Medium 1 lap Pit 32.459
Medium 28 laps Pit 22.575
Hard 2 laps -
Retired Lap 45

Redbull14. Alonso
Start P13
Medium 21 laps Pit 23.728
Hard 5 laps -
Retired Lap 26

Williams19. Massa
Start P9
Medium Qual + 14 laps Pit 22.139
Medium 18 laps Pit 22.629
Hard 14 laps Pit 22.275
Medium 19 laps -
Finished P6

McLaren22. Button
Start P14
Medium 11 laps Pit 22.589
Hard 16 laps Pit 23.327
Medium 17 laps Pit 24.066
Medium 21 laps -
Finished P16

Redbull26. Kvyat
Start P8
Medium Qual + 11 laps Pit 22.667
Medium 27 laps Pit 22.273
Hard 27 laps -
Finished P10

FI27. Hulkenberg
Start P17
Medium 10 laps Pit 22.659
Medium 16 laps Pit 22.534
Medium 23 laps Pit 22.545
Hard 16 laps -
Finished P15

Redbull28. Stevens
Start P19
Medium 16 laps Pit 24.687
Medium 16 laps Pit 23.043
Hard 15 laps Pit 22.796
Medium 16 laps -
Finish P17

Toro33. Verstappen
Start P6
Medium Qual + 13 laps Pit 24.396
Hard 24 laps Pit 22.607
Hard 28 laps -
Finished P11

Merc44. Hamilton
Start P2
Medium Qual + 13 laps Pit 24.586
Medium 19 laps Pit 22.727
Hard 19 laps Pit 21.965
Medium 15 laps -
Finished P2

Toro55. Sainz
Start P5
Medium Qual + 14 laps Pit 22.859
Hard 28 laps Pit 22.178
Hard 23 laps -
Finished P9

Redbull77. Bottas
Start P4
Medium Qual + 15 laps Pit 22.082
Medium 27 laps Pit 21.800
Hard 24 laps -
Finish P4

Redbull98. Merhi
Start P20
Medium 17 laps Pit 24.631
Medium 13 laps Pit 23.070
Hard 19 laps Pit 24.200
Hard 13 laps -
Finish P18
loading

Loading